The Redl Case – Treason in the Evidenzbureau
Contents
On 25 May 1913, Colonel Alfred Redl shot himself in a Vienna hotel. He was stationed in Prague as chief of staff of the VIII Corps and had previously been the highest-ranking counter-intelligence officer of the Danube Monarchy. For almost a decade he had worked for foreign powers. The case is regarded as one of the biggest espionage scandals before the First World War. It shows how vulnerable an intelligence service is when the very person in charge of protecting its secrets sells them.
The Evidenzbureau
The Evidenzbureau was the military intelligence service of the Austro-Hungarian General Staff. It gathered information about foreign armies and fended off enemy espionage. Redl worked there from early on. Because he spoke Russian, he joined the department dealing with Russia in 1900. In 1907 he became deputy head of the Evidenzbureau and thus had access to almost all secret documents. He introduced technical innovations in counter-intelligence and had foreign agents watched with modern methods. Later his successors used these very methods against him.
The treason: Russia, Italy and others
The main buyer of his information was the intelligence service of the Imperial Russian Army. The English-language Wikipedia calls him Russia's most important spy for the years 1903 to 1913. That is a pointed formulation that is hard to verify from the sources. What is considered certain is that Redl did not deliver only to Russia. The German Spy Museum reports that he also supplied the Italian and French intelligence services. When he was promoted to chief of staff in Prague in 1912 and transferred there, he was able to keep obtaining information through his influence.
Particularly serious is that Redl is said to have sold war plans. He is also said to have betrayed Austro-Hungarian agents in the Russian General Staff. They were hanged or took their own lives. This is a claim made by the English-language Wikipedia. I do not know of any reliable number of victims.
According to the Spy Museum, how much money Redl received for his services can hardly be established. All that is certain is that he lived lavishly. Researchers point to his love of luxury and his greed for money.
An ironic detail: When an information leak was noticed in the Evidenzbureau, his superior Arthur Giesl von Gieslingen, according to Wikipedia, tasked none other than Redl with finding the source.
The exposure
Redl's successor in counter-intelligence was Major Maximilian Ronge, whom Redl had trained himself. Ronge introduced the inspection of suspicious mail. This led to an unclaimed letter containing a large sum of cash. Ronge had the post office in Vienna watched. When someone collected the letter, he was followed and identified.
The pursuers took a taxi. They had themselves driven to the address to which the driver had taken the previous passenger. It was the Hotel Klomser. In the taxi they found a knife sheath. They handed it in at the reception and waited in the lobby to see who would collect it. It was Redl.
On the date: The sources do not entirely agree. The Spy Museum gives 25 May 1913 for the collection of the letter. The encyclopedia 1914–1918-online and the Polish article speak of 24 May or the night of 24 to 25 May. In any case, the events fell in the same night and the day before.
The end
Redl was confronted in his hotel room by a group of officers. After a short interrogation the commission left the room. He was given a loaded weapon. According to some accounts the initiative came from Chief of the General Staff Franz Conrad von Hötzendorf, according to others Redl asked for it himself. In the early morning hours of 25 May 1913 he shot himself. He left farewell letters.
Aftermath and interpretation
While the investigation was still under way, Redl's homosexuality became publicly known. Ever since, it has been debated whether it or the money was the reason for the treason. The encyclopedia 1914–1918-online points to a further effect. The public's fixation on Redl's sexuality, his taste for luxury and his greed did damage the reputation of the military, but it also distracted from shortcomings in counter-intelligence and the lack of oversight by the leadership. Conrad and the then head of intelligence August von Urbanski are named explicitly.
The affair did not end there. In January 1914 it became known that military secrets had again fallen into the wrong hands. The Evidenzbureau had not checked Redl's camera when his property was sold to pay off debts. Archduke Franz Ferdinand was angry. According to the encyclopedia, had it not been for Sarajevo he would have dismissed Urbanski in the summer of 1914 and soon removed Conrad as well.
A Polish article also places the case in its diplomatic context: it came at a time of intensified efforts to contain the Balkan War. The press used it politically.
What remains open
- The exact extent of the treason, i.e. which plans went to whom, is not clearly documented in the sources I evaluated.
- The amount of the payments is unknown.
- The motives (need for money, susceptibility to blackmail, lifestyle) are weighted differently to this day.
- The exact course of the last night is told differently in the various accounts.
Sources
- Redl, Alfred – 1914-1918-online, International Encyclopedia of the First World War
- German Spy Museum: Alfred Redl – exposed before the First World War (in German)
- Wikipedia (English): Alfred Redl
- Wikipedia (English): Maximilian Ronge
- Colonel Redl. Political motifs of the affair in Polish press releases (article, University of Poznań)
- Brewminate: Arch-Traitor Alfred Redl
