Edward Snowden and surveillance – From Room 40 to PRISM
In June 2013 a 29-year-old IT technician revealed the extent to which intelligence services read the world's communications. This text continues the series on espionage, intelligence and the power of information (Redl, Walsingham, Ems Dispatch, Russia's hybrid war). It has three parts: the revelations of 2013, signals intelligence (SIGINT) as a method, and the consequences, above all in Germany. Whether Snowden is a traitor or a whistleblower is judged differently by governments, courts and the public. I set out the positions side by side and separate what is documented from value judgements. As of: 15 November 2026.
Part 1: The revelations of 2013
The sequence of events
According to Wikipedia, between the end of May and 6 June 2013 in Hong Kong, Snowden gave NSA documents and a video interview to the Guardian reporters Glenn Greenwald and Ewen MacAskill and to the documentary filmmaker Laura Poitras. Poitras had been the first to be in contact with him. Greenwald later estimated that the collection comprised 15,000 to 20,000 documents. From early June the Guardian and the Washington Post reported on the previously unknown programmes PRISM and Boundless Informant. On 9 June 2013 Snowden revealed himself as the source at his own request. On 21 June the US Department of Justice charged him with espionage and theft of government property. Snowden flew from Hong Kong to Moscow.
What came to light
- PRISM: According to the reports, the programme had existed since 2007. It gave the NSA access to user data of large internet companies such as Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, Facebook, Skype and Apple. The companies in part spoke of legally regulated requests. The extent of their cooperation was disputed; I have not read a primary source on this here.
- Tempora: According to the Guardian, the British service GCHQ tapped into global internet traffic and exchanged large amounts of data with the NSA.
- XKeyscore: A search tool for internet traffic, which the Guardian described in July 2013 with extensive documents. It is often called the "Google of the NSA"; that is a catchphrase from a secondary source.
- Telephone data: The NSA collected metadata of telephone calls in the USA.
- Target Europe: Reports from June 2013 stated that the NSA was also spying on the European Union.
Wikipedia summarises the revelation as follows: according to it, the USA had been monitoring telecommunications, especially the internet, on a large scale and without suspicion since 2007 at the latest. The chronicle of the platform iRights also notes that in June 2013 the British government forced the Guardian to destroy hard drives containing Snowden material.
Source criticism: I have not seen the documents themselves. Most of what I know comes from newspaper reports and summaries. Wikipedia points out that some of the programmes were already known in specialist circles before 2013. What was new was the overall picture and the evidence. I do not know how many documents were published and how many remain unpublished.
Part 2: SIGINT as a method
SIGINT stands for signals intelligence, i.e. intelligence gathered by intercepting and analysing radio, telephone and data traffic. This section is an assessment based on my pages and general knowledge, not on the Snowden sources. The principle is old and has four steps: intercept, decrypt, analyse, use. What was new in 2013 was above all the scale: instead of individual radio messages, entire data streams are searched for keywords.
- First World War: My page First World War describes how the British obtained a captured German signal book from the stranded "Magdeburg" and used it in "Room 40" to read German naval radio traffic. The Zimmermann Telegram was decrypted in 1917 and passed to the USA without exposing Room 40. At Tannenberg, radio intelligence helped the Germans, as is also described there.
- Second World War: The page Coventry and Enigma deals with the question of what was known from decrypted radio messages and what was done with that knowledge.
- The intercepted letter: In the Redl case, an inspected letter led to his exposure; in Walsingham's case, it was the intercepted correspondence of Mary Stuart. This is a forerunner of postal censorship and mail inspection, which today concerns data streams. That too is my assessment.
- Today: The Heidelberg study names the cooperation of the "Five Eyes" services (USA, Great Britain, New Zealand, Canada, Australia) as the framework of global surveillance practice.
One thread connects the cases: whoever reads along must not give himself away. Room 40 and the Zimmermann Telegram show it, and the debate about Coventry raises the same question. The difference in 2013: here it was not only opponents who were eavesdropped on, but allies and uninvolved people were also captured.
Part 3: Consequences and controversy
Germany: the NSA committee of inquiry and the BND
In the summer of 2013 it was reported that EU missions and holders of fundamental rights in Germany were affected by the joint signals intelligence of the BND and the NSA. In March 2014 the Bundestag set up the NSA committee of inquiry. The BND had cooperated with the NSA in signals intelligence: it searched data diverted from an internet exchange point for characteristics specified by the NSA, the selectors. In 2016 the Federal Constitutional Court ruled that the federal government did not have to hand over the NSA selector lists to the committee. Criticism of this was sharp, for example on the WSWS website, which speaks of a "carte blanche". That is a political judgement by a party-affiliated website.
According to the Heidelberg study, the committee's objections led to a new version of the BND Act. Foreign-foreign signals intelligence was regulated by law for the first time in 2016. On 19 May 2020 the Federal Constitutional Court declared this regulation in its then form unconstitutional. The surveillance of foreigners' telecommunications abroad is bound by fundamental rights, whose protection also extends to foreigners abroad. A constitutional new regulation was, however, possible. The procedure for data transfers and cooperation with foreign services were also affected. I have not researched what has been changed since.
USA
In September 2020 the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that the mass collection of telephone data had violated the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act and may have been unconstitutional. This is reported by Global News. I do not know the details of the ruling.
Snowden himself
According to reports, Snowden wanted to travel on from Hong Kong to Ecuador, but was stranded in Moscow after the US government had cancelled his passport. Russia granted him asylum. In September 2022 President Putin granted him Russian citizenship, at his own request according to the Kremlin. Snowden defended this: he was in Russia because Washington had cancelled his passport. A spokesman for the US State Department, by contrast, stated that Snowden had long signalled his loyalty to Russia. Both are statements by those involved. The Tagesspiegel writes that no country had been willing to grant him asylum. To my knowledge, the US charges were never dropped. On his current status in 2026 I found only a dubious-looking website, which I do not use. All that is certain for today is that, as of 2022, he held Russian citizenship. You should check this for up-to-date information before publishing.
Positions side by side
- Whistleblower: In this view, Snowden exposed unlawful or at least disproportionate mass surveillance. Courts in the USA and Germany later objected to parts of the practice. That is documented, but it is not a ruling on Snowden's own actions.
- Traitor or criminal: The US government charged him with espionage and theft. That he passed on documents is undisputed. Critics point to his exile in Russia.
- In between: The court rulings on the programmes say nothing about whether the manner of disclosure was lawful.
Open questions
- What damage was done to security and sources. I have found no reliable source on this.
- How far the internet companies cooperated in PRISM.
- Snowden's current status and whereabouts.
- What has been changed in German law since the 2020 ruling.
Sources
- Wikipedia (German): Global surveillance and espionage affair
- Wikipedia (English): Global surveillance
- iRights: NSA scandal – chronology of the revelations (in German)
- bpb: Prism, Tempora, Snowden – a press review (in German)
- WeMoral: Whistleblower Edward Snowden uncovers NSA secrets (supplementary only)
- swissinfo: Whistleblower Snowden defends his Russian citizenship (in German)
- Tagesspiegel: Putin grants Snowden Russian citizenship (in German)
- Global News: Edward Snowden (news overview)
- Federal Constitutional Court: Press release on the NSA selector lists (2016, in German)
- Federal Constitutional Court: Press release 37/2020 on foreign-foreign signals intelligence (in German)
- netzpolitik.org: Mass surveillance in the BND Act is unconstitutional (in German)
- Heidelberg study: Strategic signals intelligence in the light of the BND Act (in German)
- WSWS: Federal Constitutional Court issues carte blanche for intelligence service (political judgement, in German)





